Not sure what I thought here, but using GL_IMPLEMENTATION_COLOR_READ_*
with glGetFramebufferParameteriv() is possible only since GL 4.5
(there's no extension adding it) and there's no equivalent for it in
GLES 3.1. I assumed that since the entry point is defined in 3.1 then it
would also accept the same enum, but apparently not -- and this
inconsistency is not fixed in 3.2 either.
Funnily enough, all drivers I tried (Mesa ES, SwiftShader, ANGLE) were
accepting this. The first driver that complained was ARM Mali on Huawei
P10 and there I assumed a driver bug -- but on the contrary, this is the
only driver following the spec properly :)
Now the glGetFramebufferParameteriv() API (and the DSA equivalent) is
used only on GL 4.5 contexts and up, everywhere else it's done using
the old-style glGetInteger(). I also renamed the implementations to not
misleadingly mention ES 3.1, since it has nothing to do with this. The
code path dispatch code is a bit entangled due to all the workarounds,
hopefully not breaking any behavior that worked before.
Interesting that I didn't run into this until testing on Mesa AMD
drivers. So far it worked for NV, Mesa Intel, Intel Windows, Android and
many more. Heh. Also improved the test to actually verify the user
pointer gets passed through correctly and updated the docs to reflect
this behavior.
What's left is *a lot* of places taking monstrous
std::vector<std::reference_wrapper> and that can't be changed to
std::vector<Containers::Reference> in a source-compatible way. Even that
would be only a temporary change, since the goal is to fully avoid
dependency on STL in those cases.
The final version of these APIs should take
Containers::ArrayView<Containers::Reference> and be implicitly
convertible froom e.g. std::vector<Containers::Reference>. That's
definitely possible, but not in time for 2019.01, so instead of forcing
users to temporary pass a `{vec.begin(), vec.size()}` everywhere instead
of just `vec`, I'm rather keeping these APIs intact.
This one explicitly loads GL 1.0 and 1.0 function pointers on EGL
contexts on NVidia drivers (Linux headless boxes), because somehow the
usual statically linked functions don't behave correctly.
There's much more to work around / fix, but this is a start. First we
need to create the context with a pbuffer, otherwise eglMakeCurrent()
crashes deep inside. Second, it doesn't treat EGL_CONTEXT_FLAGS_KHR as a
bitfield, so it blows up when encountering a combination of zero flags.
In that case we're simply not sending the flags there. This would also
blow up when there's more than one flag passed, but there's just one
flag for debug context at the moment, so shouldn't be a problem.
The change done in 680144f1c5 was not
properly handling these cases:
* Mesh(NoCreateT) and wrap() were not constructing the internal vector,
which blew up when move-assigning another instance.
* ~Mesh() was not destructing the internal vector if the VAO ID was
zero or non-owning wrap() was used.
Strangely enough none of these were causing *any* problems for me on
Linux (even ASan was totally quiet and due to the unfortunate
combination of bugs even when I assigned totally random data to the
storage vector). This however blew up on MSVC, assuming there the
implementation is more checked.
Because it's possible to construct Mesh with no GL context available,
the move construction and destruction needs to avoid accessing Context
unless really necessary (it would be also unclear which type of vector
should be constructed if we have no context).
Extended the tests to handle hopefully all the cases.
This is actually a preparation to make buffer-owning meshes a
possibility (where I would need an union of vectors otherwise),
nevertheless it removes the dependency on a vector.
Was Magnum::GL::Extensions::GL before and the redundancy was completely
unnecessary. Potential future extensions coming from GLX, EGL or whatnot
will most probably be in the Platform namespace in a completely separate
file, so this is not a problem.
All code internal to the GL library is affected, not much the outside,
as that is handled by the compatibility alias.
This is quite big, so:
* There are new Magnum::PixelFormat and Magnum::CompressedPixelFormat
enums, which contain generic API-independent formats. In particular,
PixelFormat replaces GL::PixelFormat and GL::PixelType with a single
value.
* There's GL::pixelFormat(), GL::pixelType(),
GL::compressedPixelFormat() to convert the generic enums to
GL-specific. The mapping is only in one direction, done with a lookup
table (generic enums are indices to that table).
* GL classes taking the formats directly (such as GL::BufferImage) have
overloads that take both the GL-specific and generic format.
* The generic Image, CompressedImage, ImageView, CompressedImageView,
and Trade::ImageData classes now accept the generic formats
first-class. However, it's also possible to store an
implementation-specific value to cover cases where a generic format
enum doesn't have support for a particular format. This is done by
wrapping the value using pixelFormatWrap() or
compressedPixelFormatWrap(). Particular GPU APIs then assume it's
their implementation-specific value and extract the value back using
pixelFormatUnwrap() or compressedPixelFormatUnwrap(). There's also an
isPixelFormatImplementationSpecific() and
isCompressedPixelFormatImplementationSpecific() that distinguishes
these values.
* Many operations need pixel size and in order to have it even for
implementation-specific formats, a corresponding pixelSize()
overload is found via ADL on construction and the calculated size
stored along the format. Previously the pixel size was only
calculated on demand, but that's not possible now. In case such
overload is not available, it's possible to pass pixel size manually
as well.
* In order to support the GL format+type pair, Image, ImageView and
Trade::ImageData, there's now an additional untyped formatExtra()
field that holds the second value.
* The CompressedPixelStorage class is now unconditionally available on
all targets, including OpenGL ES and WebGL. However, on OpenGL ES the
GL APIs expect that it's all at default values.
I attempted to preserve backwards compatibility as much as possible:
* The PixelFormat and CompressedPixelFormat enum now contains generic
API-independent values. The GL-specific formats are present there,
but marked as deprecated. Use either the generic values or
GL::PixelFormat (togehter with GL::PixelType) and
GL::CompressedPixelFormat instead. There's a lot of ugliness caused
by this, but seems to work well.
* *Image::type() functions are deprecated as they were too
GL-specific. Use formatExtra() and cast it to GL::PixelType instead.
* Image constructors take templated format or format+extra arguments,
so passing GL-specific values to them should still work.
The general part stays in the root namespace, while the GL-specific
stuff goes to the GL namespace. Also all GL-specific documentation was
moved to relevant APIs in the GL namespace. This finally allows me to
build PixelStorage.cpp as part of the root namespace.
The PixelStorage::pixelSize() function and
PixelStorage::dataProperties() taking a pair of GL::PixelFormat /
GL::PixelType enums is deprecated, use GL::pixelSize() and
dataProperties() taking pixel size directly instead. A lot of code is
still using these, including images; the deprecated aliases are inlined
in the header to avoid a compile-time dependency on the GL library.
At the moment just the GL library itself w/o the tests, and without
backwards compatibility aliases. The following types were left in the
root namespace, despite being in the GL/ directory, as they will get
moved back soon:
* Image, CompressedImage and their dimensional typedefs
* ImageView, CompressedImageView and their dimensional typedefs
* PixelStorage
Not PixelFormat etc., that one will stay in the GL namespace and a
completely new PixelFormat enum will be provided in the root namespace.
Minimal updates (just the include guards) so Git is hopefully able to
detect the rename and track the history properly.
Everything except Magnum::GL doesn't compile now.
Vladimír Vondruš